| Most Goals, Both Teams: 9 |
| (11-Mar-00 Tottenham Hotspur 7-2 Southampton) [PR] |
| (12-Feb-00 West Ham United 5-4 Bradford City) [PR] |
| (08-Jan-00 Colchester United 5-4 Bristol Rovers) [D2] |
| (28-Aug-99 Barnet 6-3 York City) [D3] |
| Most Goals, One Team: 8 |
| (19-Sep-99 Newcastle United 8-0 Sheffield Wednesday) [PR] |
| Biggest Home Victory: 8 |
| (19-Sep-99 Newcastle United 8-0 Sheffield Wednesday) [PR] |
| Biggest Away Victory: 6 |
| (26-Feb-00 Chester City 1-7 Brighton & Hove Albion) [D3] |
